Why Pierre Nkurunziza’s Third-Term Bid Caused a Crisis

The crisis sparked by Pierre Nkurunziza’s third-term bid in Burundi in 2015 was primarily caused by a fundamental disagreement over the interpretation of the country’s constitution and the Arusha Accord, a peace agreement designed to prevent a recurrence of civil war. Many perceived his decision to run for another term as a direct violation of these foundational documents, leading to widespread protests, a failed coup attempt, and a sustained period of political instability and violence.

The Constitutional and Arusha Accord Clash

At the heart of the crisis lay conflicting interpretations of Burundi’s legal framework, specifically regarding presidential term limits. The dispute centred on whether Nkurunziza’s first term, during which he was elected by parliament rather than popular vote, counted towards the two-term limit stipulated in both the 2005 Constitution and the 2000 Arusha Peace and Reconciliation Agreement.

The Two-Term Limit Provision

Both the Burundian Constitution of 2005 and the Arusha Accord clearly stipulated a two-term limit for the presidency. Article 96 of the Constitution states: “No one may serve more than two presidential terms.” Similarly, Protocol II, Article 7.3 of the Arusha Agreement specifies that “The President of the Republic shall be elected for a five-year term, renewable once only.” The intent of these provisions was to prevent the concentration of power in one individual and to foster democratic rotation, a crucial element in a country with a history of ethnic conflict and authoritarian rule.

Nkurunziza’s supporters argued that his first term, from 2005 to 2010, was a transitional one. They contended that because he was elected by an indirect parliamentary vote, and not by universal suffrage, it should not be counted towards the two-term limit. Their reasoning was that the spirit of the law applied to terms where the president had received a direct popular mandate. This interpretation was championed by the ruling CNDD-FDD party and supported by the Constitutional Court, which controversially ruled in May 2015 that Nkurunziza was eligible to run. However, the integrity of this court ruling was immediately called into question, with one of its vice-presidents reportedly fleeing the country and alleging undue pressure and threats.

Conversely, the opposition, civil society organisations, and a significant portion of the international community vehemently maintained that both the constitution and the Arusha Accord were unambiguous. They argued that any term served as president, regardless of the method of election, counted towards the limit. Their position was that allowing Nkurunziza to run for a third term would fundamentally undermine the constitutional order and, crucially, the delicate power-sharing arrangements established by the Arusha Accord. For them, a third term was a blatant power grab that threatened to unravel the peace process.

The Significance of the Arusha Accord

The Arusha Peace and Reconciliation Agreement, signed in 2000, was more than just a peace deal; it was the bedrock of post-civil war Burundi. It ended a brutal civil war that had claimed hundreds of thousands of lives and established a framework for power-sharing, democratic governance, and reconciliation between the Hutu and Tutsi ethnic groups. The accord enshrined principles of inclusion, political pluralism, and respect for human rights, with term limits being a critical safeguard against the re-emergence of authoritarianism and ethnic domination.

The agreement’s provisions on term limits were seen as vital to preventing any single individual or group from entrenching themselves in power indefinitely, which could lead to resentment and renewed conflict. By seeming to disregard this key provision, Nkurunziza’s bid was perceived as a direct attack on the spirit and letter of the Arusha Accord. This threatened to dismantle the very foundations of peace and stability that had been painstakingly built over a decade. Opponents feared that if one fundamental tenet of the accord could be disregarded, others might follow, plunging the country back into its dark past. The perception was that the accord was a package deal; you couldn’t cherry-pick the parts you liked and discard those you didn’t.

Widespread Protests and Civil Unrest

The announcement of Nkurunziza’s intention to seek a third term ignited a firestorm of public outrage, leading to widespread and sustained protests across Burundi, particularly in the capital, Bujumbura. These demonstrations represented a broad cross-section of society, united by their opposition to what they viewed as an unconstitutional power grab.

Public Reaction and Demonstrations

Starting in late April 2015, immediately after the CNDD-FDD nominated Nkurunziza, thousands of Burundians took to the streets. The protests were initially peaceful, with demonstrators chanting slogans, holding placards, and attempting to march towards the city centre. The mood was one of defiance and determination, driven by a deep sense of betrayal and a fear for the country’s democratic future. People from various walks of life – students, civil servants, shopkeepers, and even some members of the ruling party’s youth wing, the Imbonerakure – participated, reflecting the broad discontent.

The demonstrations were characterised by significant youth participation, many of whom had grown up in the post-Arusha era and valued the democratic gains. They felt their future was being jeopardised by a leader clinging to power. The protests also saw a notable involvement of women, often at the forefront, who felt the impact of instability most keenly. The opposition parties and civil society groups played a crucial role in mobilising and organising these protests, providing a platform for the widespread public anger.

Government Crackdown and Escalation

The government’s response to the protests was swift and brutal. Security forces, including the police and elements of the army, were deployed to disperse demonstrators, often using excessive force. Live ammunition, tear gas, and water cannons became common sights on the streets of Bujumbura. Journalists and human rights activists reported arbitrary arrests, detentions, and instances of torture. This heavy-handed approach only served to further inflame public anger and solidify opposition to the government.

As the crackdown intensified, the protests grew in intensity and scale, often turning violent as demonstrators clashed with security forces. Barricades were erected in residential areas, particularly in opposition strongholds, making certain neighbourhoods no-go zones for government forces. The government also moved to shut down independent media outlets, including popular radio stations that had been crucial in disseminating information and mobilising protesters, effectively creating an information blackout for many. This suppression of dissent was a clear indication that the government was unwilling to tolerate any challenge to Nkurunziza’s bid. The escalating violence led to a growing number of casualties, both among protesters and security forces, and began to generate a humanitarian crisis as people started to flee the country.

The Failed Coup Attempt

In mid-May 2015, during a period of intense protests and as Nkurunziza was attending a summit in Tanzania, a faction within the military launched a coup attempt, dramatically escalating the crisis.

Details of the Coup

On 13 May 2015, Major General Godefroid Niyombare, a former army chief of staff and intelligence chief who had been sacked by Nkurunziza months earlier, announced on a private radio station that he was overthrowing the president. Niyombare declared the formation of a “National Council for the Restoration of the Arusha Accord and Constitutional Order” and stated that Nkurunziza’s third-term bid was unconstitutional. His announcement was met with scenes of jubilation in the streets of Bujumbura, with protesters celebrating what they hoped would be an end to the crisis.

The coup plotters attempted to seize key strategic locations, including the national radio and television broadcaster (RTNB) and the presidential palace. They called on soldiers to join them and urged the civilian population to remain calm but to support their efforts. The timing was strategic, as Nkurunziza was out of the country, potentially creating a power vacuum that the coup plotters hoped to exploit. Niyombare himself had been a respected figure within the military, known for his role in the peace process and seen by some as a unifying figure.

Loyalists vs. Coup Plotters

The coup, however, quickly unravelled due to strong resistance from elements within the Burundian military loyal to President Nkurunziza. General Prime Niyongabo, the army chief of staff, swiftly condemned the coup attempt and declared it a “fantasy.” Fierce clashes erupted between loyalist forces and coup plotters, particularly around the RTNB headquarters, which became a symbolic battleground. Loyalists eventually managed to regain control of the state broadcaster, broadcasting messages of allegiance to Nkurunziza.

The failure of the coup can be attributed to several factors: a lack of broad, unified support within the military, particularly from key command structures; the swift and decisive action of loyalist forces; and the fact that Nkurunziza quickly returned to the country, consolidating his authority. Within days, the coup attempt was quashed. Major General Niyombare and several other senior coup leaders went into hiding or were arrested. Some were killed during the operation to suppress the coup. The failure of the coup had profound implications. It emboldened Nkurunziza and his loyalists, allowing them to crack down even harder on dissent, framing all opposition as part of a treasonous plot. It also eliminated a potential internal military check on his power, further entrenching his position and pushing the country deeper into crisis.

Regional and International Responses

The escalating crisis in Burundi quickly garnered significant attention from regional bodies, international organisations, and individual nations, all expressing deep concern over the potential for widespread violence and instability.

African Union and East African Community Efforts

The African Union (AU) and the East African Community (EAC) were at the forefront of diplomatic efforts to resolve the crisis. Both organisations, particularly the EAC, which Burundi is a member of, recognised the severe implications of the crisis for regional stability. The EAC convened emergency summits, with heads of state attempting to mediate between the Burundian government and the opposition. They called for a postponement of the elections and urged Nkurunziza to respect the constitution and the Arusha Accord. Tanzania’s then-President Jakaya Kikwete played a prominent role in these initial mediation efforts.

The AU also condemned the violence and dispatched envoys to Bujumbura to engage with all parties. It urged for a political dialogue and offered to send peacekeepers, though this offer was later rejected by Nkurunziza’s government, which viewed it as an infringement on its sovereignty. Both organisations consistently stressed the importance of upholding constitutional order and adherence to the principles of good governance and democracy. However, despite their efforts, these regional interventions ultimately proved largely ineffective in swaying Nkurunziza or in bridging the deep divide between the government and the opposition. The Burundian government consistently resisted external pressure, maintaining that the issue was an internal matter and accusing external actors of interference.

United Nations and Western Concerns

The United Nations (UN) also became heavily involved, expressing alarm over the deteriorating human rights situation and the potential for the crisis to spiral into mass atrocities. The UN Security Council held multiple sessions on Burundi, passing resolutions that called for dialogue, an end to violence, and accountability for human rights abuses. The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights issued strong condemnations of the government’s crackdown and documented numerous abuses. Special envoys were appointed to try and facilitate negotiations.

Western countries, including the European Union and the United States, also voiced strong criticism of Nkurunziza’s third-term bid and the subsequent violence. They issued travel bans, froze assets of key government officials, and suspended various forms of aid to Burundi, citing concerns over human rights violations and the undermining of democratic institutions. They consistently reiterated their support for the Arusha Accord and pressed for inclusive political dialogue. However, similar to the regional efforts, these international pressures, while significant, did not deter Nkurunziza from pursuing his third term and, in some cases, were viewed by the Burundian government as biased and unwelcome interference. The government often played on nationalist sentiments, portraying itself as resisting external domination.

Long-Term Consequences and Impact

Metric Data/Description
Year of Third-Term Announcement 2015
Constitutional Term Limit Two terms
Number of Protesters Thousands nationwide
Casualties During Crisis Over 100 deaths reported
Number of Arrests Hundreds of opposition members and protesters
International Response Condemnation from African Union and Western countries
Impact on Political Stability Increased ethnic tensions and political unrest
Economic Impact Decline in foreign investment and tourism

The decision by Pierre Nkurunziza to pursue a third term and the subsequent handling of the crisis had profound and long-lasting negative consequences for Burundi, affecting its political landscape, social fabric, economy, and international standing.

Political and Security Deterioration

The crisis plunged Burundi into a prolonged period of political instability and insecurity. The government effectively consolidated power, suppressing all forms of opposition, both political and civil society. Many opposition leaders and activists were forced into exile, arrested, or disappeared. The political space for dissent shrank dramatically, leading to a de facto one-party rule under the CNDD-FDD. Elections held in 2015, boycotted by the opposition, were widely regarded as illegitimate, further eroding democratic institutions.

Security deteriorated significantly, particularly in the immediate aftermath of the coup attempt and the highly contested elections. There were reports of extrajudicial killings, arbitrary arrests, and torture, primarily targeting perceived opponents of the government. Armed groups emerged, challenging the state, and retaliatory violence became common. The once unified army, a cornerstone of the Arusha Accord, became increasingly politicised and fractured, leading to concerns about its long-term stability and neutrality. This created an atmosphere of fear and suspicion throughout the country.

Human Rights and Refugee Crisis

The human rights situation in Burundi rapidly deteriorated to alarming levels. Reports from the UN and various human rights organisations documented widespread abuses, including enforced disappearances, arbitrary detentions, torture, and sexual violence. The Imbonerakure, the ruling party’s youth wing, was accused of acting as a de facto militia, intimidating and persecuting government opponents with impunity. Freedom of expression, assembly, and association were severely curtailed.

The violence and repression triggered a massive humanitarian crisis. Hundreds of thousands of Burundians fled the country, seeking refuge in neighbouring countries like Tanzania, Rwanda, Uganda, and the Democratic Republic of Congo. Refugee camps swelled, placing immense pressure on host communities and international aid agencies. These refugees, many of whom were educated professionals and business owners, represented a significant loss of human capital for Burundi, further hindering its development prospects. The exodus of such a large segment of the population underscored the deep fear and lack of trust in the government’s ability to protect its citizens.

Economic Decline and International Isolation

The political crisis had a devastating impact on Burundi’s already fragile economy. International donors, including key Western nations and the European Union, suspended or significantly reduced aid, which Burundi was heavily reliant upon. Foreign investment plummeted due to the instability and uncertainty. Businesses struggled, and many closed down or moved operations elsewhere. The tourism sector, once a small but growing industry, collapsed entirely.

Unemployment surged, particularly among the youth, exacerbating social tensions. Inflation rose, and the national currency depreciated, leading to a decline in living standards for ordinary Burundians. Essential services like healthcare and education, which were heavily dependent on foreign aid, suffered significantly.

Internationally, Burundi became increasingly isolated. Its relationship with several regional and Western partners soured considerably. While some African nations maintained engagement, the country faced widespread condemnation for its human rights record and its perceived disregard for democratic norms. This isolation, combined with the economic decline, left Burundi in a precarious position, struggling to recover from the self-inflicted wounds of the crisis triggered by a president’s determination to cling to power. The long-term effects continue to be felt, shaping the country’s trajectory long after Nkurunziza’s death in 2020.

FAQs

What was the main reason for Pierre Nkurunziza’s third-term bid?

Pierre Nkurunziza’s bid for a third term in office was primarily based on his interpretation of the Burundian constitution, which he argued allowed him to run again. His supporters claimed that his first term did not count as he was elected by parliament rather than through a popular vote.

How did the public react to Nkurunziza’s decision to run for a third term?

The public reaction was largely negative, leading to widespread protests across the country. Many citizens viewed his decision as a power grab that threatened the democratic process and stability of Burundi, resulting in significant unrest and violence.

What were the consequences of the crisis triggered by Nkurunziza’s third-term bid?

The crisis resulted in a severe political and humanitarian situation in Burundi, including a crackdown on dissent, mass arrests, and an increase in violence. It also led to a refugee crisis, with thousands fleeing to neighbouring countries to escape the turmoil.

How did the international community respond to the situation in Burundi?

The international community expressed concern over the escalating violence and human rights abuses in Burundi. Various countries and organisations imposed sanctions on Nkurunziza’s government and called for dialogue to resolve the crisis, although efforts to mediate were often met with resistance.

What impact did Nkurunziza’s third-term bid have on Burundi’s political landscape?

Nkurunziza’s third-term bid significantly altered Burundi’s political landscape, leading to increased authoritarianism and the suppression of opposition parties. The crisis deepened divisions within the country and undermined the peace agreements that had previously ended a civil war, resulting in long-term instability.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top